Generic searches for alternative gravitational wave polarizations with networks of interferometric detectors

Abstract

The detection of gravitational wave signals by Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo enables us to probe the polarization content of gravitational waves. In general relativity, only tensor modes are present, while in a variety of alternative theories one can also have vector or scalar modes. Recently test were performed which compared Bayesian evidences for the hypotheses that either purely tensor, purely vector, or purely scalar polarizations were present. Indeed, with only three detectors in a network and allowing for mixtures of tensor polarizations and alternative polarization states, it is not possible to identify precisely which nonstandard polarizations might be in the signal and by what amounts. However, we demonstrate that one can still infer whether, in addition to tensor polarizations, alternative polarizations are present in the first place, irrespective of the detailed polarization content. We develop two methods to do this for sources with electromagnetic counterparts, both based on the so-called null stream. Apart from being able to detect mixtures of tensor and alternative polarizations, these have the added advantage that no waveform models are needed, and signals from any kind of transient source with known sky position can be used. Both formalisms allow us to combine information from multiple sources so as to arrive at increasingly more stringent bounds. For now we apply these on the binary neutron star signal GW170817, showing consistency with the tensor-only hypothesis with p-values of 0.315 and 0.790 for the two methods.