A finitary treatment of the closed fragment of Japaridze’s provability logic

Abstract

We study a propositional polymodal provability logic GLP introduced by G. Japaridze. The previous treatments of this logic, due to Japaridze and Ignatiev (see [11, 7]), heavily relied on some non-finitary principles such as transfinite induction up to ε0 or reflection principles. In fact, the closed fragment of GLP gives rise to a natural system of ordinal notation for ε0 that was used in [1] for a proof-theoretic analysis of Peano arithmetic and for constructing simple combinatorial independent statements. In this paper, we study Ignatiev’s universal model for the closed fragment of this logic. Using bisimulation techniques, we show that several basic results on the closed fragment of GLP, including the normal form theorem, can be proved by purely finitary means formalizable in elementary arithmetic. As a corollary, the system of ordinal notation for ε0 based on the closed fragment of GLP is shown to be provably isomorphic to the standard system of ordinal notation up to ε0. We also settle negatively some conjectures by Ignatiev.