Three-dimensional management needs of deep-sea hydrothermal vent ecosystems

Abstract

Deep-sea hydrothermal vents form small, unique, and fragile ecosystems that are widely recognized as sites in need of protection. Deep-seabed mining (DSM) is a future threat to hydrothermal ecosystem integrity. In most areas within, and in all areas beyond national jurisdiction, currently proposed protection measures from DSM are unlikely to be sufficient, as only the known active venting sites on the seafloor are intended to be protected from DSM impacts. To ensure effective protection, we propose protecting not only the active vent sites but the entire hydrothermal ecosystems and their transition zones, embracing the seafloor, subseafloor and overlying water column. We discuss how ecological knowledge supports the proposed three-dimensional (3-D) protection. We suggest no DSM extraction or indirect impacts on the seafloor and entire subseafloor within a minimum 50 km diameter (25 km radius) around visible active vents. This will ensure the maintenance of subseafloor connections that are key for ecosystem integrity, as changes in vent fluid conditions can alter all ecosystem functions and services linked to venting activity. In the water column, protection from pollution from the seafloor to surface is suggested to protect vent larvae. This extent spans the entire length of ridges or back-arc basins, with a cross-axial extent of 80 km. We further discuss how international law can contribute to the effective protection of vent ecosystems and transition zones in international waters, and provide guidance for coastal States to safeguard these ecosystems and transition zones within their own maritime areas.