Multi-Observer Study on Diagnostic Accuracy of Pediatric Renal Tumors Imaged with Higher-Harmonic-Generation Microscopy

Abstract

Background/Objectives: Wilms tumors, the most common pediatric renal tumors, are heterogeneous and consist of varying amounts of three components: blastema, epithelium, and stroma. Postoperative chemotherapy is tailored based on risk group classification and stage. Due to this heterogeneity, pathologists perform extensive tumor sampling to ensure accurate classification. Higher-harmonic-generation microscopy (HHGM) is an innovative imaging technique that enables rapid visualization of fresh tissue without preparation or staining. This makes it particularly valuable for sample selection, as the tissue can be reused for further analysis. This study aims to evaluate the accuracy of pathologists in distinguishing normal renal tissue, abnormal renal tissue, and three types of pediatric renal tumors, Wilms tumor, renal cell carcinoma, and congenital mesoblastic nephroma, in HHGM images. Methods: Twenty-nine samples from eighteen patients with a pediatric renal tumor were imaged using an HHG microscope and subsequently processed for histological analysis. Overview images of the samples were acquired at a rate of 10 s per mm2, while high-quality images took 1 min per mm2. A multi-observer study involving ten international expert pathologists of the SIOP-RTSG was conducted. Results: Pathologists were able to differentiate between normal and abnormal tissue with 100% (29/29) accuracy and correctly identified tumor versus non-tumor tissue with 97% (28/29) accuracy. Conclusions: These results show that HHGM is a highly promising technique for the rapid assessment of pediatric renal tumor samples, particularly for evaluating sample representativeness.