Picturing disturbed body experience: A comparison of body drawings in persons with somatoform disorder and a general population sample

Abstract

People with somatic symptom disorder or somatoform disorder are considered to have a troubled relationship to their body that is hard to assess with self-report questionnaires alone. To examine the potential value of own-body drawings as an assessment tool, objective features of drawings from 179 patients referred to treatment for somatoform disorder, were compared to those of 173 age-and-sex matched persons from the general population. While two factors had been found in the somatoform disorder sample, in the general population only the factor that reflected ‘details’ in own-body drawings was replicated. The two samples did not score differently on this factor. The general population sample showed a less strong association between objective body drawings scores on this ‘details’ factor and self-reported scores of body experience than the somatoform disorder sample. Moreover, the phenomenological contents of the drawings were more oriented towards health or appearance than the mostly mixed or unclear orientation of persons with somatoform disorder. Because the objective scoring of body drawings did not differ between groups while the contents of body drawings appeared to differ, the results suggest that this objective scoring of body drawings is not appropriate to distinguish people with and without somatoform disorder.